I was surprised to learn of the letter sent by Congressman Jerry Nadler – who is my Congressman, by the way – to Attorney General Eric H. Holder requesting the attorney general to investigate as the New York Times stated
“whether the police in New York and other cities had deprived protesters of rights protected by the Constitution or by law, and to determine what can be done to prevent future similar actions.”
His letter was a reference to the Occupy Wall Street protest, which used Zuccotti Park as its base. Mayor Michael Bloomberg quite understandably criticized the Congressman for requesting such an investigation. Had I been Mayor, I would have similarly protested.
Indeed, when I was Mayor, other members of Congress at the time, at the request of some civil rights activists, demanded the House Judiciary Committee investigate charges of police brutality alleging biased racial actions by the NYPD. The current ranking member of the Judiciary Committee, John Conyers (D-MI), then a senior member of the committee responding to the demand of the advocates, first and prior to hearings denounced the city and the NYPD, then held hearings, and then announced the charges against the NYPD were not sustained. But the damage was done and, or course, the holding of the hearing itself gave credibility to the false charges.
So here too the Congressman’s letter gives credibility to the false charges of advocates for Occupy Wall Street. The protesters occupied Zuccotti Park for two months before the City of New York, acting pursuant to court order, removed the tents and sleeping bags that had been erected against City directives. Occupy Wall Street is represented by well qualified lawyers to argue the merits of their case in court. They did so and lost. They have a right of appeal. It is reputed that they have a bank account available to them of more than $500,000 as a result of donations. Their rights, in my opinion, have not been violated. Just the opposite. The protestors have violated the rights of others doing business or living in the area of Zuccotti Park. Congressman Nadler and the Speaker of the Assembly Shelly Silver jointly complained by letter to the Mayor, stating “Some of the protesters have created serious and quality of life concerns for residents.” So Nadler, as often happens with public officials trying to please constituents, ended up on both sides of the issue.
The forum to determine rights and wrongs in this case are the New York courts. Does Nadler believe they are incapable of doing so and that the US Attorney General needs to enter the matter? That is a real smack in the face to New York City, and undeserved.
Occupy Wall Street protesters on December 17th tried to illegally occupy a parcel of land owned by Trinity Church
, which had declined to make it available as an encampment for Occupy Wall Street protesters. Protesters were arrested by the NYPD for their attempted illegal occupation. Did Congressman Nadler condemn Trinity Church, the NYPD or the Occupy Wall Street protesters? Or, is he leaving that issue to the New York courts?
I will now venture an opinion. Congressman Nadler represents the Upper West Side, a bastion of liberalism and radicalism. Citizens flood him with letters and visits demanding he side with Occupy Wall Street. He decides that since he’s criticized Occupy Wall Street by letter to the Mayor at the request of business people and residents of the area near Zuccotti Park, why not now ingratiate himself with Occupy Wall Street by demanding an investigation of the NYPD and its tactics? As they say, “It can’t hurt.” But it does hurt. In this case it attacks the integrity and professionalism of the police, which most New Yorkers would say in this case is unfair. By and large and with few exceptions, the police handled themselves with restraint and professionalism.
I hope the Attorney General will conclude the New York courts can and should handle the matter. Nadler’s political correctness, seeking to please the advocates, is seen for what it is – the craven response of a politician worried about a possible primary from the left.
Click here to return to Blog home page